Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles: Which Is Better For Your Indiana Property?
Aug 03, 2026A new roof is a substantial investment for any homeowner, and it also plays a huge factor in the safety and efficiency of your house. It’s no surprise that you’ll want to seek out the best roofing material for your Indiana home. At Rodeffer Roofing, we make it easy to explore the right roofing system for your property, with sturdy and high-performing options in asphalt, metal, and flat roofing. We know that, when it comes to durable roofing options in Indiana, most homeowners are weighing the decision between a metal roof vs. asphalt shingles.
With that in mind, let’s explore these two highly popular choices in more detail.
Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles: The Pros and Cons
What are some benefits of metal roofing in Midwest Indiana, and is it truly worth it? What’s the lifespan and energy efficiency of a metal roof system vs. asphalt shingles? Both of these roofing materials perform well in harsh weather, making them a great choice for Indiana homes. But there are other factors that can set these two options apart:
Cost
One of the biggest differences between a metal and shingle roof in Indiana is the cost. Generally speaking, metal roofing can come at a bigger price point, while asphalt shingles offer fantastic value for your spend. That said, you can minimize the cost factor if your roofing contractor offers financing, which is something that’s available from Rodeffer Roofing.
Longevity
Metal roofing has a reputation for a lengthy lifespan, so that may be a consideration depending on your roofing company. That said, the right asphalt shingles can also boast exceptional longevity. In fact, with Rodeffer Roofing, you’ll have access to Owens Corning® asphalt shingle roofing, which comes with a 50-year warranty!
Style
One of the biggest differences between these two roofing systems is their overall appearance. Standing seam metal roofing comes in long metal panels which are interlocked for a sleek look. Asphalt shingles are often available in a greater variety of colors and styles, giving you plenty to choose from.
Maintenance
Traditionally, metal roofing will require less upkeep than asphalt shingles. That’s because individual shingles can wear down, or may be more susceptible to damage. Our hardwearing asphalt shingles come with proprietary algae resistance as well as SureNail® Technology, which makes our shingles more capable of handling high winds.
About Our Roofing Systems
At Rodeffer Roofing, we’re proud to furnish homes throughout East Central Indiana with top-of-the-line roofing systems that stand the test of time. We combine premium products with exceptional workmanship and dedicated customer care.
When it comes to asphalt shingle roofs, we bring you options from trusted manufacturer Owens Corning. These roofing systems are incredibly durable against all kinds of weather events and extreme temperatures, and offer gorgeous visual appeal for any style of home. Plus, they’re customizable in a number of eye-catching color options.
Our roofing contractor can also bring you fantastic choices for high-strength metal roofing. We offer standing seam metal roof systems for excellent energy-efficiency and beauty, with different colors and profiles to suit your needs. These roofing options are fire-resistant and remarkably high-performing, making them an appealing option for any property in East Central Indiana.
And don’t forget about our financing options! We make it easy to get the brand-new roof you need for your home.
Get Started with Rodeffer Roofing
Still weighing a metal roof vs. asphalt shingles? For homeowners in East Central Indiana, Rodeffer Roofing can walk you through your options in more detail. Contact us today for an instant quote.
